Could better monitoring and tracking of funding accelerate the transition to open access?

Springer Nature Group
By: Carrie Webster, Mon Apr 6 2020
Carrie Calder

Author: Carrie Webster

Vice President Open Access, Springer Nature

Springer Nature is committed to enabling a faster transition to open access (OA). As colleagues have written about previously on this blog, enabling immediate OA is one part of a broader goal to make all research as open as possible, in order to advance science and discovery. That’s why we continue to innovate our business models and workflows to make choosing and supporting OA as easy as possible for authors, institutions and funders.

One of the key responsibilities we have as a leading OA publisher is to examine the problems limiting a transition to full OA. With that in mind, we have today released a new whitepaper that explores the role that increased monitoring and tracking of OA funds - and increased harnessing of complex funding sources - might play in speeding up the transition to OA.

The whitepaper includes results from a survey with just over 1,000 Springer Nature authors who had paid an APC from June to August 2019. We asked them to highlight the funding sources they used to cover the cost of their APC. We also then commissioned 16 interviews with institutional contacts who were responsible for OA management, asking them about their workflows relating to APC monitoring and tracking. The findings in particular point to the importance of harnessing ‘APCs in the wild’ - payments that are harder to monitor and that institutions and funders may be unaware of, for example because they came from research grant funds, institutional funds not specifically for OA, from co-authors, or an author’s personal funds.


The funding of OA is complex

As noted above, we undertook this project with the expectation that institutions find it difficult to effectively monitor APC spend. Our author survey confirmed just how complex the funding landscape is, making it clear why effective tracking is challenging:

There is no dominant source of APC funding for authors publishing in either fully OA or hybrid journals. Our survey showed authors are drawing on research funders, institutions, publisher agreements, and other sources (e.g. personal funds) to finance APC paymentsNearly half of respondents (47% of fully OA authors, 44% of hybrid OA authors) combine two or more of these main sources of funding in order to cover their APC


Many APCs are ‘wild’

We define ‘wild’ as funds less easily monitored by an institution or research funder: so for example where an author pays from an institutional OA fund or via a publisher agreement, the APC is typically straightforward to track, but an APC paid from a main research grant is more difficult to track.

Over a quarter (27%) of Springer Nature authors surveyed used only 'wild' funding sources for their APCA further 50% combined an APC funding source ‘in the wild’ with funds from more easily monitored sourcesThis is figure is even higher for fully OA authors, with 29% using only ‘wild’ funding sources and a further 54% using ‘wild’ funds in combination with other sourcesRegionally we see variation that points to the success of dedicated APC funding - for example the UK had the lowest levels of APCs 'in the wild', with 50% using funds 'in the wild', either alone (12.5%) or in combination with other funds (37.5%). This compares to  92% of fully OA authors in North America who were using APC funding sources 'in the wild', either alone (35%) or in combination with other funds (57%)

Our institutional interviews confirmed that institutions are finding it challenging to track APC payments. In fact although nearly all institutions had workflows in place to track publications from the institution, far fewer were tracking APC payments. One described the task of monitoring as a “bureaucratic headache”, and even where tracking systems are in place the “evidence is hard to collect”.


By introducing effective monitoring and tracking, and by harnessing these combined funds, there is a real opportunity to accelerate a transition to OA

The results from our author survey show the challenges that institutions are facing, and our interviews begin to show what workflows might enable better monitoring and tracking of APC payments. The success stories our interviewees shared suggest that gains could be made through institutional policy, whereby authors are required to tell their institution about OA publications; or by accounting codes that help consistency in reporting APC payments; or through establishing centralised payment hubs. All of these actions require a high level of coordination and also investment, but certainly indicate that effective APC monitoring is achievable.

Many interviewees also pointed to the success of OA agreements - including transformative agreements - in reducing the complexities around APC payment and monitoring. As more APCs are managed via a central agreement, the number of micro payments (or individual APC invoices) will be reduced, and the number of individual APCs that need to be tracked by a separate accounting code therefore diminishes. The agreements also enable authors to make their research openly available with minimal administrative effort, making it as easy as possible for authors to choose OA.

To facilitate greater numbers of OA agreements, or to consolidate a central OA fund for researchers, it is clear that institutions and research funders need to bring together the complex sources of funding being utilised to pay for OA. By doing so, OA becomes easier to manage, with greater efficiencies for all - including authors.

We have throughout our 20-year history of OA publishing worked to collaborate with others, including research funders and institutions, to innovate our business models and workflows for OA. We are proud of the role we have played in shaping both OA business models and discussion. Together, publishers, funders, institutions and the whole scholarly communications industry have a part to play in enabling a successful OA transition. An immediate action for us following this initial research is to validate these findings and broaden our understanding of institutional monitoring and tracking of APC payments. For that reason, we intend to collect and share further insights from institutions on the barriers and enablers for APC monitoring, and encourage feedback on the models this whitepaper has identified.


*The full whitepaper can be downloaded here*

Carrie Calder

Author: Carrie Webster

Vice President Open Access, Springer Nature

Carrie has worked in open access for 15 years.  Starting her publishing career at BioMed Central in 2003, she was involved in the early growth of the OA movement, BioMed Central’s journal portfolio, as well as the evolution of institutional membership models. 

Moving from STM to HSS, Carrie joined Palgrave Macmillan in 2012.  As Director of Market Development, she developed Palgrave’s OA policies, launched their open access monograph program and first fully OA journal in HSS.

In her current role, Carrie is responsible for OA policy and open research business development across Springer Nature.  This includes green and gold policies, OA books, institutional OA partnerships, as well as supporting the development of a portfolio c.600 fully OA journals, and data initiatives.

Carrie is a member of various industry associations and boards including:- OASPA’s policy committee, the PA's Academic, Professional & Learning Publishers Council, and UK Open Access Monograph Steering Group.

Related Tags:

Previous posts

Research Practices in the wake of COVID-19: Busting open the myths around open data

Springer Nature. Figshare and Digital Science report on COVID-19's impact on open data and research practices.

R
Research Publishing
07 Aug 2020
Understanding better the impact of COVID-19 on the research enterprise

Commissioned research to better understand challenges faced by universities and researchers worldwide.

Springer Nature Group
06 Aug 2020
Why we need Pride, now more than ever

SN Pride talks through its commitment to pushing for diversity in our communities.

Springer Nature Group
10 Jul 2020
A message from Frank Vrancken Peeters, our CEO

We are shocked by events in the US. We stand united against racism and discrimination of any kind. 

Springer Nature Group
05 Jun 2020
Future-proofing research data – it’s a question of TRUST

Varsha Khodiyar discusses the TRUST principles for digital repositories & repositories key role in open research.

Springer Nature Group
08 Jun 2020
Research assessment: The continuing debate for balance

Alison Mitchell discusses metrics and research following Springer Nature's signing of DORA.

Springer Nature Group
19 May 2020
Laying the foundations for open access: from ambitious beginnings to the publishing mainstream

From ambitious beginnings to the publishing mainstream - BMC on 20 years of OA 

Springer Nature Group
13 May 2020
Opening doors to discovery of content and data with AI

Value in publishing

Why are partnerships an essential part of using technology to make content and data discoverable.

A
Advancing Discoveries
16 Apr 2020
Could better monitoring and tracking of funding accelerate the transition to open access?

Advancing discovery

White paper explores the fragmented and varied funding currently available for APCs.

Springer Nature Group
06 Apr 2020
Coronavirus pandemic: Nature’s pledge

Advancing discovery

London | 27th March 2020

Nature's pledge in the fight against COVID-19

Springer Nature Group
26 Mar 2020
Accelerating progress in support of the sustainable development goals

Advancing discovery

Springer Nature's third Responsible Business Report.

Springer Nature Group
26 Mar 2020
A message from Frank Vrancken Peeters

Advancing discovery

Springer Nature's CEO in response to the COVID-19 crisis

Springer Nature Group
19 Mar 2020
Of Mythical Beasts and Zero-Embargo Mandates

Advancing discovery

Dean Sanderson discusses Springer Nature's position on the rumored Executive Order.

O
Openaccess
28 Feb 2020
What is needed to drive the OA transition in 2020?

Advancing discovery

Susie Winter considers what needs to happen in 2020 to make the OA transition a reality.

R
Research Publishing
23 Jan 2020
Alternative conditions needed for cOAlition S’s Transformative Journal proposal to succeed

Springer Nature's response to latest consultation published by cOAlition S

R
Research Publishing
17 Dec 2019
Announcing a new diversity commitment for Springer Nature’s research publishing

Taking an active role in accelerating progress on equality, diversity & inclusion.

R
Research Publishing
11 Dec 2019
 Making Open Data a central part of Open Research:  Steps publishers can and should take today

Open data

Attitudes to data sharing are changing, but clear gaps in how researchers are being supported remain. What steps can publishers take today? Grace Baynes explores.

R
Research Publishing
11 Nov 2019
Why being 'open' matters

Advancing discovery

Why does open access matter? What is it enabling us as a community to do? How does it support the wider goal of open research? Steven Inchcoombe reflects.

R
Research Publishing
24 Oct 2019
Think global, act global

This Global Goals Week we at Springer Nature are asking ourselves what we can do to help bring people together and to join the dots between research and the solutions we need to build a better, more sustainable world.

Springer Nature Group
26 Sep 2019
Celebrating the Chinese contribution to the world’s sustainable development research

With the fastest-growing scientific and scholarly research, China’s importance for sustainable development is increasingly clear.

R
Research Publishing
28 Aug 2019
Transformative deals substantially aid the transition to OA. Let’s give them the time they need to do so.

Last month, Springer Nature agreed a new transformative ‘read and publish’ deal with the Norwegian library consortium, Unit.  This, coupled with renewals of existing deals in the UK (Jisc), Sweden (Bibsam) and Qatar, takes the number of such deals we have into double figures, the most of any publisher.  These deals enable researchers in these ten countries to publish open access in over 1900 Springer journals as well as read the research of others across this portfolio.

O
Openaccess
02 Aug 2019
The future of open access books

Open access book publishing has been growing in recent years. The Directory of Open Access Books (DOAB) lists 2,099 open access books published in 2018, an increase of 38% from 2017. Funders are also starting to engage with open access for books: a small number of European funders now mandate open access for books and provide financial support for open access book publication. COAlition S has also indicated that they support transitioning monographs to open access, and will provide guidance by the end of 2021.

O
Openaccess
18 Jun 2019
Maximising the benefits of early sharing

At Springer Nature making great research available as quickly as possible is a central part of our commitment to the research community. 

Springer Nature Group
23 May 2019
A faster path to an open future

At Springer Nature we want to find the fastest and most effective route to immediate open access (OA) for all primary research.

Springer Nature Group
08 May 2019
A postcard from Davos: what role for research at this gathering of global opinion leaders?

My first impressions of Davos? Dazzling, overwhelming, unexpected, thought-provoking, incredibly busy and much, much more…

R
Research Publishing
04 Apr 2019
Businesses must play a role in sustainable development

Today Springer Nature launches its Responsible Business report for 2018.

Springer Nature Group
27 Mar 2019
Setting targets at Springer Nature to help create a better balance

The theme of this year’s IWD couldn’t be more relevant to us. Last month, Springer Nature’s management board announced to our 13,000 colleagues that we will set a target to improve gender representation in our leadership group.

Springer Nature Group
07 Mar 2019
Congratulations to Karen Keskulla Uhlenbeck

It’s a great pleasure for us at Springer Nature to congratulate Karen Keskulla Uhlenbeck for the award of this year’s Abel Prize.

Springer Nature Group
03 Mar 2019
Without you, we are nothing: why community engagement is at the core of everything we do

Sometimes there is great value in stating the obvious; the scholarly publishing industry would not exist without a broad international community of researchers, students, librarians, funders, and commercial partners.

R
Research Publishing
06 Mar 2019
How Can We Accelerate Data Sharing?

What steps can publishers, funders and institutions take to make data sharing worth a researcher’s time and energy, and accelerate progress? 

R
Research Publishing
10 Mar 2019
Connecting curious minds to advance learning and discovery

Science

Springer Nature will stay curious, connect ideas, question how things are done, explore new ways to deliver for our communities and then make the changes that matter.

R
Research Publishing
20 Feb 2019
Need to focus on demand as well as supply: making Plan S work for all

Steven Inchcoombe discusses Springer Nature's submission to the cOAlition of participants to make Plan S work for all.

R
Research Publishing
11 Feb 2019
The quest for more value: A Long Read

Research News

Daniel Ropers shares some of his early observations about the academic publishing industry.

R
Research Publishing
01 Nov 2018
Publication misconduct: changing the conversation

Suzanne Farley discusses how to increase prevention and detection of research and publication misconduct. 

R
Research Publishing
04 Nov 2018
Lessons learned from open peer review: a publisher’s perspective

Research News

Rachel Burley discusses BMC's history in openness and transparency and what has been learnt.

R
Research Publishing
23 Dec 2017
Accelerating open access: what is missing from Plan S

Research News

The transition to open access needs to be sustainable for the whole research community.

R
Research Publishing
23 Dec 2017
Finding the science in social media

Research News

At Springer Nature we believe that social media is a vital tool for everyone involved in the academic research and publishing process. 

R
Research Publishing
23 Dec 2017
Hybrid journals can advance the move towards full open access

Blogs

Hybrid journals play an important role in the transition to open access.

R
Research Publishing
01 Aug 2018
Science benefits from diversity – and as publishers we have a role to play

As a progressive publisher, we have a responsibility to support diversity and inclusion.

R
Research Publishing
17 Jul 2018
What next for Impact Factors?

Why we need to work together to create metrics that better meet the needs of the research community.

R
Research Publishing
02 Jul 2018
Can research change the world?

Springer Nature believes that great multidisciplinary research needs to be informing global discussions.  

R
Research Publishing
28 Jun 2018
We need to do more to celebrate and support women in engineering

Women’s achievements in STEM fields need to be harnessed to raise awareness, create role models and foster a more inclusive culture. 

R
Research Publishing
21 Jun 2018
Future of the book all down to definition

Advancing discovery

The speed of recent change in the publishing industry in the past 10 years poses the question, what will book publishing look like in the future?

R
Research Publishing